Investing can be complicated, technical, time-consuming, and, for many, not very interesting. As a result, many individuals seek the guidance of experienced and trustworthy financial professionals.
But whom can we trust? Whom can we feel comfortable and confident with our hard-earned assets, personal information, and financial futures? On whom can we rely to put our interests first?
Expectation and the law
There are two sides to the trust coin that are completely distinct, but often confused. First, there is expectation. We approach every commercial transaction with some notion about the other party and the extent to which our interests align. For instance, we may fairly expect our local grocer to sell only fresh, safe, and accurately labeled products. But we would not necessarily expect him to put our interests ahead of his all or even most of the time. We understand that he is in business to make a profit, and it would be naive to expect him to put our interests first when, for instance, he sets a price for fresh produce. Nor would we expect him to reveal the price he paid the wholesaler or the other inner workings of his business.
Our expectation of trust of the grocer is a work in progress, built over time through experience. In general, we expect to be treated in a way that earns our repeat business. In other transactions, our expectation of trust may be higher or lower. We always hope for good treatment from the mechanic, carpenter, and car dealer, but we recognize that these and other vendors have their own interests that will almost always come first. In most business relationships we keep our expectations pretty low, knowing our greatest protections are care and
skepticism. That is, let the buyer beware.
On the flip side of expectation is legal responsibility. The grocer can be held liable if he knowingly sells tainted meat or produce. The carpenter can be held responsible for causing damage to property. “Lemon laws” provide some recourse against buying a car with incurable problems. But beyond these simple protections, sellers of products and services are rarely required by law to put the interests of their customers ahead of their own.
Investing is different
Trust in the financial services arena is ruled by the same two-sided coin — what we expect, and what the law requires. We expect good treatment from our financial advisors. We know trust and honesty are essential to create financial plans and portfolios that serve our financial and family interests. We expect advisors to suggest sound investments that align with our needs, time horizon, and comfort with risk. Our expectations of financial professionals is relatively high; in general, we view financial advisors as worthy of our trust.
On the legal side of the coin is fiduciary duty. Fiduciary duty is a legal duty of care, loyalty, honesty, and good faith. As SEC Commissioner Luis Aguilar described in a speech to the Investment Advisers Association Annual Conference on May 7, 2009,
“… A fiduciary has an
affirmative obligation to put a client’s interests above his or her own. As a
result, a fiduciary acts in the best interests of the client, even if it means
putting a client’s interest above his own. …A fiduciary standard…is an
affirmative obligation of loyalty and care that continues through the life of
the relationship between the adviser and the client, and it controls all aspects
of their relationship. It is not a check-the-box standard that only periodically
applies.”1
To a far greater extent than in most businesses, investment advisors are legally bound to put the interests of clients ahead of their own. This means, among other things:
- Selecting investments based on client needs, not on compensation or career
success for the advisor - Disclosing any markups on transactions for client accounts
- Revealing any existing or potential conflicts of interest
- Disclosing any sources of compensation that could influence the guidance of
the advisor - Transparency in all dealings, guidance, and decisions
These are fundamental protections — similar to those that apply to doctors, lawyers, and CPAs — that validate the expectation of trust we bestow on financial professionals. They are true legal obligations, not mere ethical
standards or industry guidelines. Violations can mean the end of a career and other penalties.
An important distinction
Fiduciary duty means that advisors are obligated by law to protect investor interests. However, not all financial professionals are bound by fiduciary duty. Registered Investment Advisors (RIAs) are. But broker-dealers typically are not. Broker-dealers serve clients, but work for their employers.
Broker-dealers (Brokerage Firms) are not required by law to recommend investments that are in the best interest of clients. Instead, they must meet a much lower standard — suitability. A recommended investment must be suitable for the investor, generally meaning only that the levels of risk and sophistication are appropriate.
The suitability standard allows brokers to pursue their own interests without disclosing those interests. Brokers are free to, for example, recommend mutual funds that earn commissions or bonuses for themselves, or sell bonds from the brokerage’s in-house inventory at undisclosed markups. In making a recommendation, a broker is not required to disclose the compensation she may receive, or discuss that other similar suitable, or better, investments may be available at lower prices. She is not required to seek out on behalf of her clients investments with low transaction or management fees.
Compared to fiduciary duty, suitability is a lower bar. Because of this important distinction between fiduciaries and brokers — a distinction unknown or unclear to many investors — many brokers include this language on account agreements and promotional materials:
“Your account is a brokerage account and not an advisory account. Our interests may not always be the same as yours. Please ask us questions to make sure you understand your rights and our obligations to you, including the extent of our obligations to disclose conflicts of interest and to act in your best interest. We are paid both by you and, sometimes, by people who compensate us based on what you buy. Therefore, our profits, and our salespersons’ compensation, may vary by product and over time.” 2
One of the regulatory reforms under consideration to close the gap between advisors and brokers is to require brokers to adhere to a fiduciary standard, but at this time, no such requirement applies.
No surprises
To be sure, a suitability standard is acceptable for many investors, and does not preclude a broker from providing sound guidance and earning a high level of client trust. However, every investor should fully understand the legal boundaries within which a financial professional operates.
And by the same token, a professional designation alone should never merit blind trust. Before working with any financial professional, investors should exercise thorough due diligence — ask questions, review resumes, and talk to other clients. And remember that an expectation of trust and legal duty are two different sides of the same coin — connected but distinct.
As recent scandals remind us, just seeming trustworthy is not nearly enough.
1www.sec.gov
2from HarrisBank.com Brokerage Accounts page
2009 Bright Sky Group, LLC. All rights reserved.
Bright Sky Group, LLC is not a registered investment adviser. The views expressed by Bright Sky Group represent the opinions of members of Bright Sky Group, but should not be construed as financial or investment advice. Further, the views are subject to change and are not intended as a forecast or guarantee of future results. The material provided by Bright Sky Group is for informational purposes only. Statements of future expectations, estimates or projections, and other forward looking statements are based on available information deemed reliable, but the accuracy of such information cannot be guaranteed. Statements are based on assumptions that may involve known and unknown risks and uncertainties. Past performance is not indicative of future results.
Bright Sky Group member firms are each registered investment advisers, which are independently owned and operated from each other. Bright Sky Group provides general financial information. The services, securities and
financial instruments described by Bright Sky Group may not be available to or suitable for you, and not all strategies are appropriate at all times. The value and income of any of the securities or financial instruments mentioned herein can fall as well as rise, and an investor may get back less than he or she invested. Foreign-currency denominated securities and financial instruments are subject to fluctuations in exchange rates that could have a positive or adverse affect on the value, price or income of such securities and financial
instruments. Independent advice should be sought for an investor’s specific needs.
“A fiduciary standard…is an affirmative obligation of loyalty and care
that continues through the life of the relationship between the adviser and the
client, and it controls all aspects of their relationship. It is not a
check-the-box standard that only periodically applies.” — SEC Commissioner
Luis Aguilar